Last week we watched the first three of the V/H/S films. We had already seen the first two, though it had been a while, so didn't really remember them terribly well. (There are also a fourth, fifth, and upcoming sixth film, but unfortunately those are all Shudder exclusives. Maybe this will be the year I chuck an extra $6 per month at my TV for a couple months for more horror stuff, but I haven't yet.) We watched them out of order, but I'll review them in order, lol.
These are all anthology films, each featuring a frame story that chains the other short films together. As is fairly typical, this leads to a little bit of variable quality in the segments, but at the same time I really do like anthology films in the broad sense. There are some ideas that really ARE best expressed as short stories, and stretching them into a feature-length film makes them less punchy and more prone to filler, and it's relatively difficult to find an audience for short films outside of anthologies.
V/H/S
The frame story ("Tape 56"), directed by Adam Wingard, is... nothing to write home about, but it serves its purpose of giving the rest of it an excuse to happen.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My thoughts: )
"Amateur Night" is pretty good. I like a lot of the feature films this director (David Bruckner) has gone on to do: The Ritual, The Night House, the new Hellraiser... he also did a segment in Southbound which is one of my favorite anthology horror films I've seen.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
This segment was expanded into a full-length film called Siren, but I haven't seen it!
"Second Honeymoon," (directed by Ti West) isn't too bad, but is probably my least favorite of the segments.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
"Tuesday the 17th," directed by Glenn McQuaid is one I enjoyed. It's got a fun "unexplained" angle in my opinion.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
Also, I like the title's reference to Friday the 13th.
"The Sick Thing That Happened to Emily When She Was Younger", directed by Joe Swanberg, is one of the least gory, though it's the one that's most disturbing in my opinion, because despite the supernatural element to it, the "real" horror is gaslighting and abuse.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
"10/31/98", directed by the Radio Silence collective, is another one I like. It's probably in the middle of my list in terms of which ones I enjoyed the most. It's not a super complex story, but I feel like it did a simple premise well.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
V/H/S/2
I feel pretty similarly about the first and second films. I think both have some great segments that stand out pretty well, and overall I enjoyed both of them.
The frame story in V/H/S/2, "Tape 49", directed by Simon Barrett, has more of a twist to it than the frame story in the first movie, and is similarly decent in its utility as an excuse to chain the other segments together.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
It's a less subtle spooky than the first film's frame story starts out with, but it does its job!
It's a bit interesting to me that the frame story has more of a twist to it this time around, because the various segments actually rely far LESS on having twists to them as compared to the first film. In general, I feel pretty neutral about that? It was sort of a nice throughline for all the stories in the first set, though as a whole I don't think these feel like they're missing something by comparison.
"Phase I Clinical Trials", directed by Adam Wingard, feels a bit like a Black Mirror episode, and it's one that I could see being a pretty decent longer-form film. Or at least an hour-long Black Mirror episode, ha.
( Summary: )
( The ending is: )
( My further minorly spoilery opinion: )
"A Ride in the Park" was directed by Eduardo Sanchez and Gregg Hale (of The Blair Witch Project fame.) I enjoy this one for being a bit blackly funny.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My thoughts: )
"Safe Haven", directed by Timo Tjahjanto and Gareth Evans, is another one that I would watch as a longer film, and is definitely my favorite of the segments.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My thoughts: )
"Slumber Party Alien Abduction", directed by Jason Eisener, is by far my least favorite segment, which makes it a little sad to me that it was the one that DID get turned into a feature film.
( Summary: )
( My thoughts: )
V/H/S:Viral
This one sucked. Lol, I did discover that was not an unpopular opinion: it is by far the worst-reviewed of any of the franchise. But yeah, I did not like it. That was a bit of a bummer, because I did enjoy the first two, and particularly found segments out of both the first two films that really stuck with me. The third one? Nah.
The frame story this time is "Various Circles", directed by Marcel Sarmiento.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My thoughts: )
Dante the Great, directed by Gregg Bishop was... kind of mediocre.
( Summary: )
( The ending is: )
( My thoughts: )
Parallel Monsters, directed by Nacho Vigalondo was a more interesting idea, but it came across as a bit sillier than I think may have been intended.
( Summary: )
( After that: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
Bonestorm, directed by Justin Benson and Aaron Scott Moorhead is definitely my favorite of the segments, but that's a bit of a low bar this time around.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
As a whole, I think this one lacked the at least sort of cohesive feel that the other two did. As mentioned above, the larger scale frame story felt to me like it changed the tone of the series, and not in a good way.
Well that shit got long and kept getting longer.
I would recommend the first two films, on the strength of their best segments, if nothing else. I would not recommend the third, ha. Be advised that there is absolutely a lot of gore and nudity (including multiple instances of full-frontal female nudity), definitely sometimes falling into the “gratuitous” camp.
These are all anthology films, each featuring a frame story that chains the other short films together. As is fairly typical, this leads to a little bit of variable quality in the segments, but at the same time I really do like anthology films in the broad sense. There are some ideas that really ARE best expressed as short stories, and stretching them into a feature-length film makes them less punchy and more prone to filler, and it's relatively difficult to find an audience for short films outside of anthologies.
V/H/S
The frame story ("Tape 56"), directed by Adam Wingard, is... nothing to write home about, but it serves its purpose of giving the rest of it an excuse to happen.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My thoughts: )
"Amateur Night" is pretty good. I like a lot of the feature films this director (David Bruckner) has gone on to do: The Ritual, The Night House, the new Hellraiser... he also did a segment in Southbound which is one of my favorite anthology horror films I've seen.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
This segment was expanded into a full-length film called Siren, but I haven't seen it!
"Second Honeymoon," (directed by Ti West) isn't too bad, but is probably my least favorite of the segments.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
"Tuesday the 17th," directed by Glenn McQuaid is one I enjoyed. It's got a fun "unexplained" angle in my opinion.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
Also, I like the title's reference to Friday the 13th.
"The Sick Thing That Happened to Emily When She Was Younger", directed by Joe Swanberg, is one of the least gory, though it's the one that's most disturbing in my opinion, because despite the supernatural element to it, the "real" horror is gaslighting and abuse.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
"10/31/98", directed by the Radio Silence collective, is another one I like. It's probably in the middle of my list in terms of which ones I enjoyed the most. It's not a super complex story, but I feel like it did a simple premise well.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
V/H/S/2
I feel pretty similarly about the first and second films. I think both have some great segments that stand out pretty well, and overall I enjoyed both of them.
The frame story in V/H/S/2, "Tape 49", directed by Simon Barrett, has more of a twist to it than the frame story in the first movie, and is similarly decent in its utility as an excuse to chain the other segments together.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
It's a less subtle spooky than the first film's frame story starts out with, but it does its job!
It's a bit interesting to me that the frame story has more of a twist to it this time around, because the various segments actually rely far LESS on having twists to them as compared to the first film. In general, I feel pretty neutral about that? It was sort of a nice throughline for all the stories in the first set, though as a whole I don't think these feel like they're missing something by comparison.
"Phase I Clinical Trials", directed by Adam Wingard, feels a bit like a Black Mirror episode, and it's one that I could see being a pretty decent longer-form film. Or at least an hour-long Black Mirror episode, ha.
( Summary: )
( The ending is: )
( My further minorly spoilery opinion: )
"A Ride in the Park" was directed by Eduardo Sanchez and Gregg Hale (of The Blair Witch Project fame.) I enjoy this one for being a bit blackly funny.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My thoughts: )
"Safe Haven", directed by Timo Tjahjanto and Gareth Evans, is another one that I would watch as a longer film, and is definitely my favorite of the segments.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My thoughts: )
"Slumber Party Alien Abduction", directed by Jason Eisener, is by far my least favorite segment, which makes it a little sad to me that it was the one that DID get turned into a feature film.
( Summary: )
( My thoughts: )
V/H/S:Viral
This one sucked. Lol, I did discover that was not an unpopular opinion: it is by far the worst-reviewed of any of the franchise. But yeah, I did not like it. That was a bit of a bummer, because I did enjoy the first two, and particularly found segments out of both the first two films that really stuck with me. The third one? Nah.
The frame story this time is "Various Circles", directed by Marcel Sarmiento.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My thoughts: )
Dante the Great, directed by Gregg Bishop was... kind of mediocre.
( Summary: )
( The ending is: )
( My thoughts: )
Parallel Monsters, directed by Nacho Vigalondo was a more interesting idea, but it came across as a bit sillier than I think may have been intended.
( Summary: )
( After that: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
Bonestorm, directed by Justin Benson and Aaron Scott Moorhead is definitely my favorite of the segments, but that's a bit of a low bar this time around.
( Summary: )
( The twist is: )
( My minorly spoilery opinion: )
As a whole, I think this one lacked the at least sort of cohesive feel that the other two did. As mentioned above, the larger scale frame story felt to me like it changed the tone of the series, and not in a good way.
Well that shit got long and kept getting longer.
I would recommend the first two films, on the strength of their best segments, if nothing else. I would not recommend the third, ha. Be advised that there is absolutely a lot of gore and nudity (including multiple instances of full-frontal female nudity), definitely sometimes falling into the “gratuitous” camp.